News and Analysis of Artificial Intelligence Technology Legal Issues
A collage of individual images in an image data set

The Role of Explainable Artificial Intelligence in Patent Law

Although the notion of “explainable artificial intelligence” (AI) has been suggested as a necessary component of governing AI technology, at least for the reason that transparency leads to trust and better management of AI systems in the wild, one area of US law already places a burden on AI developers and producers to explain how their AI technology works: patent law.  Patent law’s focus on how AI systems work was not borne from a Congressional mandate. Rather, the Supreme Court gets all the credit–or blame, as some might contend–for this legal development, which began with the Court’s 2014 decision in Alice…

Federal Circuit: AI, IoT, and Robotics in “Danger” Due to Uncertainty Surrounding Patent Abstraction Test

In Purepredictive, Inc. v. H2O.ai, Inc., the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California (J. Orrick) granted Mountain View-based H2O.ai’s motion to dismiss a patent infringement complaint. In doing so, the court found that the claims of asserted U.S. patent 8,880,446 were invalid on the grounds that they “are directed to the abstract concept of the manipulation of mathematical functions and make use of computers only as tools, rather than provide a specific improvement on a computer-related technology.” Decisions like this hardly make news these days, what with the frequency by which software patents are being invalidated by…